CROSS Rulings: How to Search, Read, and Tell If One Binds You

Key Points
- CROSS at rulings.cbp.gov is CBP's public database of ruling letters, searchable by tariff number, keyword, or ruling number.
- A ruling letter binds CBP personnel on the transaction it describes, but it is directed to the person it was issued to, so a ruling on someone else's product is not a ruling you hold.
- A classification ruling applies only to articles identical to the sample submitted or identical in description to the ruling.
- A ruling marked revoked no longer states CBP's position, and one marked modified states it only as modified.
- Prior rulings on similar goods are valuable research and support for a reasonable-care file under 19 U.S.C. 1484.
On this page
- How to search CROSS
- How to read a ruling letter
- Does a CROSS ruling bind your entry?
- Revoked and modified rulings
- What importers should do
- Key references
The links in this article go to the primary documents: the regulations, statutes, and official CBP and tariff schedule pages themselves. Read the source.
CROSS, the Customs Rulings Online Search System, is CBP's public database of ruling letters at rulings.cbp.gov. You can search it by tariff number, keyword, or ruling number. A ruling found there binds CBP only for the transaction and the person it was issued to, so a ruling on another company's product is strong research for your classification but not a ruling you can claim as your own.
How to search CROSS
CROSS holds ruling letters issued under the administrative ruling rules in 19 CFR Part 177. Pick the search method that matches what you already know.
Search by tariff number
Enter a heading or subheading from the Harmonized Tariff Schedule to see how CBP has ruled on goods placed there. This is the best starting point when you have a candidate classification and want to test it. Also search the neighboring headings you rejected, since rulings often explain why a product does not belong somewhere.
Search by keyword
Search on the product's name, material, function, and any trade term. Run several variants: the common name, the technical name, and the material composition. Keyword results are only as good as your wording, so a single search that returns nothing does not mean CBP has never ruled on similar goods.
Search by ruling number
If a supplier, broker, or protest decision cites a ruling, enter the number to pull the full text. Current rulings from the National Commodity Specialist Division in New York carry a number that begins with N. Current rulings from Regulations and Rulings at Headquarters carry a number that begins with H. Older rulings in the database carry earlier number formats and are still searchable, so do not discard a result because its number looks unfamiliar.
How to read a ruling letter
Most classification rulings follow the same sequence. Read them in this order.
- The facts. The description of the product: composition, dimensions, how it is made, how it is used, and how it is sold. This is the part that decides whether the ruling is relevant to you.
- The issue. The question CBP was asked, usually which tariff provision applies.
- The holding. CBP's answer, including the reasoning that applies the General Rules of Interpretation and the legal notes to the described facts.
- The tariff provision. The classification itself, the heading and subheading that CBP assigned to the described goods.
Compare the facts line by line against your product. A small difference in material, construction, or intended use can move goods to a different provision. Note too whether the ruling lists the duty treatment and any other applicable provisions as of its date, because those can change independently of the classification reasoning.
Does a CROSS ruling bind your entry?
The governing rules are in 19 CFR 177.9. Three points matter.
- Binding effect on CBP. Under 19 CFR 177.9(a), a ruling letter is the official position of CBP on the transaction it describes and binds CBP personnel until it is modified or revoked.
- Identical goods only. Under 19 CFR 177.9(b)(2), a classification ruling applies only to articles identical to the sample submitted or to articles whose description is identical to the description in the ruling.
- Directed to the requester. Under 19 CFR 177.9(c), a ruling is directed to the person it was issued to. Other persons should not rely on it or assume its principles will be applied to another transaction.
The practical result: a ruling issued to a competitor or supplier does not protect your entry, even if the goods look the same. It is persuasive research. It shows how CBP reasoned and gives you a defensible basis for your own classification, but the ruling itself is not yours.
Using other parties' rulings in a reasonable-care file
Importers must use reasonable care when entering goods, as provided in 19 U.S.C. 1484. A documented search of CROSS, with the relevant rulings, a comparison of facts, and your reasoning for following or distinguishing each one, is good evidence of that care. Save the search terms and the ruling text with your classification memo.
To get a ruling you can actually hold, see how to request a binding ruling before you import. For the difference between a ruling and what a port does at entry, see binding ruling letters versus port decisions.
Revoked and modified rulings
Always check the status of a ruling before relying on it.
- A ruling marked revoked no longer states CBP's position.
- A ruling marked modified states CBP's position only as modified, so read the modifying ruling too.
Under 19 U.S.C. 1625(c) and 19 CFR 177.12, CBP modifies or revokes a ruling that has been in effect for at least 60 days only after notice and comment. That process means a change to a long-standing position is published before it takes effect. The mechanics are covered in the 60-day notice process for ruling revocation and modification.
Do not assume that a search result with no revocation flag is current in every respect. Check the date, confirm that the tariff provision it cites still exists in the current schedule, and look for later rulings on the same goods.
What importers should do
- Search CROSS by tariff number, keyword, and ruling number for every new product, and record the searches and results in the classification file.
- Compare the facts of each ruling to your product, and document why you follow or distinguish it.
- Confirm that each ruling is not revoked or modified before citing it.
- Request your own ruling when the entry volume or the classification risk justifies a written answer you can rely on.
Key references
- CBP CROSS (rulings.cbp.gov): the public database of CBP ruling letters.
- 19 CFR Part 177: the administrative rulings regulations.
- 19 CFR 177.9: the legal effect of ruling letters and who may rely on them.
- 19 CFR 177.12: modification and revocation of rulings.
- 19 U.S.C. 1625: the statute requiring notice and comment before modifying or revoking long-standing rulings.
- 19 U.S.C. 1484: the importer's entry and reasonable-care obligation.
- Harmonized Tariff Schedule: the official tariff schedule used to confirm provisions cited in rulings.